An Outstanding Album
5
By Muppetus
This album is not the best place for an introduction to Cohen's work, nor is filled with his most immediately accessible songs. That much said, 'Dear Heather' is a brilliant and beautiful offering, full of lyrical grace and subtly crafted music. With this work Leonard Cohen leaves little doubt that, even as he approaches his mid-seventies, he remains the master of a very deep and elegant darkness.
There are one or two tracks on 'Dear Heather' that could be done without; 'Dear Heather' itself (the title track) is obtuse in its meaning and rather unpleasant to the ears. Likewise, the song 'Because Of' is perhaps a trifle too self-indulgent; this account of how women continue to pay special attention to Cohen in his advanced age makes the poet/songwriter sound like a dirty old man.
But those missteps are exceptions. Every other track on 'Dear Heather' offers something deep and lovely. As a statement of faith, 'There For You' is a masterpiece and possibly the most powerful single song on the album. 'Undertow' is an understated and very moving piece. 'On That Day' is probably the best song anyone has yet written about September 11th, being as direct and succinct as it is. 'Nightingale' is a pure and pretty number. 'To a Teacher' is a fantastic expression of gratitude and longing that makes superb use of its uncoventional lyrical form. 'Go No More A-Roving' is a fine tribute to Lord Byron and a fitting kind of swan-song for a romantic like Cohen. 'The Letters' is an excellent song and so is 'Morning Glory'. 'Villanelle For Our Time' is an effective inclusion, following 'On That Day' and thereby functioning as a kind of restatement of the American faith in the wake of the September 11th terror attacks.
To my taste, 'The Faith' is a bit schmaltzy and 'Tennessee Waltz' is just okay, but both are nice and neither are unwelcome.
In the final analysis, Cohen is simply the finest writer presently working in the medium of popular song. He has maintained that distinction for decades now and 'Dear Heather' only serves as further evidence of his considerable talents. This album is outstanding and well worth owning.